
Our obligatory cautionary note: We need to be skeptical of all of the “walls are closing in on Trump this time” wish-casting, because we’ve been here so many times before. But the headlines are grim, the numbers are sour, and the mood is bleak, even as the nutbaggery flows down like waters and the crazy like a mighty stream.
So, while all of this may just be noise, you can be forgiven if you also detect a signal: MAGA, once a monolith of cultishness, is showing cracks. MTG is out; leading right-wing influencers are fighting over whether it’s cool to be Nazi; Trump’s poll numbers are craptastic; Republicans are fretting about a mid-term blowout; and “Team Trump fumbles one legal battle after another — and starts new one.”
Happy Tuesday. A quick note to readers:
Keeping track of Trump’s corruption is, unfortunately, a full-time job. So is chronicling his attacks on American values and institutions. That’s why I do this, and why independent media has become so important. This is the challenge of our time and the fight of our generation. But we can’t do it without your help.
Trump’s Retribution Faceplant
By now you’ve undoubtedly read about the spectacular crash and burn of Trump’s signature cases of revenge: “Judge dismisses cases against James Comey”, Letitia James - The Washington Post
U.S. District Judge Cameron McGowan Currie ruled that Lindsey Halligan, the prosecutor overseeing both cases, had been unlawfully appointed to her position and, therefore, indictments she secured against Comey and James must be thrown out.
Currie’s decision would allow the Justice Department to seek a new indictment against James under a lawfully appointed prosecutor. In Comey’s case, though, the judge suggested the time to do so has run out.
The Wall Street Journal calls Trump’s DOJ: “The Gang That Couldn’t Indict Straight”
President Trump’s lawfare revenge tour has gone bust…. In its rush for retribution, the Trump Administration cut corners.
So, there was most definitely ketchup on the gilded walls of the White House. But rather than recalibrating, Trump dove in deeper, launching a scorched earth attack on yet another popular Democrat. On Monday, “the Pentagon announced that it would perform a ‘thorough review’ of ‘serious allegations of misconduct’ against Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.). The Pentagon said Kelly could be recalled for active duty ‘for court-martial proceedings or administrative measures.’”
Kelly’s “offense”? The decorated veteran appeared in a video with five other former military or intelligence officers, telling troops that they “can refuse illegal orders.” Which is actually the law.
So, this is unlikely to end well. Notes the Independent:
Kelly is a popular senator in Arizona, a state Trump won. He also served in the U.S. Navy as a captain and as an astronaut — he flew four space missions and his identical twin brother Scott is also a retired NASA astronaut — before he ran for Senate in 2020 after his wife, then-Rep. Gabrielle Giffords was shot in the head in a political assassination attempt in 2011. Kamala Harris had him on her shortlist to be her running mate.
But he sent Trump into a rage last week when he – along with fellow Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.), Democratic Reps. Jason Crow, Chrissy Houlahan, Maggie Goodlander and Chris DeLuzio – released a video telling active duty U.S. servicemembers that they could refuse to obey illegal orders.
As the AP notes, “It is extraordinary for the Pentagon, which until President Donald Trump’s second term had usually gone out of its way to act and appear apolitical, to directly threaten a sitting member of Congress with investigation. It comes after Trump ramped up the rhetoric by accusing the lawmakers of sedition ‘punishable by DEATH’ in a social media post days after the video was released last week.”
But I humbly suggest that this is not the split screen Donald Trump wants. Here is Kelly’s fiery response: “If this is meant to intimidate me and other members of Congress from doing our jobs and holding this administration accountable, it won’t work,” Kelly said in a statement.
**
Make sure you read David French’s piece here. French notes that members of the military have an obligation to follow orders they believe are legal. But he offers this hypothetical scenario:
Imagine that you’re on the ground, the leader of an infantry platoon. You capture a man you believe to be the mastermind of a series of suicide bombings, including an explosion at a wedding last week that killed dozens of women and children.
Just when you’re about to load your prisoner into a vehicle to take him to your forward operating base, the company commander arrives. He takes one look at your prisoner, turns to you, and says, “I’ve seen what that man did. I picked up the body parts of babies. Kill him. He doesn’t deserve to live.”
What do you do?
On Tuesday, six Democratic lawmakers released a video message to members of the military. The group was organized by Senator Elissa Slotkin, a former C.I.A. analyst who served in Iraq during the height of the war there. The group included Senator Mark Kelly, a former fighter pilot and astronaut, and Representative Jason Crow, a former Army Ranger. All six lawmakers were veterans of either the military or the intelligence services.
The message of the video was simple: Soldiers do not have to follow illegal orders.
There is nothing radical about that statement. Members of the military are trained on the basics of the law of war. Over the course of my JAG career, I briefed thousands of soldiers, and in each of those briefings I told them that if they were ordered to violate any of the clear requirements of the law, they didn’t just have the right to refuse; they had an obligation to refuse.
Trump’s reaction to the video was unhinged. On social media, he posted, “SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR, punishable by DEATH!” Another post he shared said, “HANG THEM GEORGE WASHINGTON WOULD !!”
Those statements are ridiculous. It is not “seditious” to repeat a simple legal truth to the American troops.
**
But wait. It gets worse.
Data Points of Decline
As you know, we do not chuff hopium here, but let’s catch-up on what seems like it just might be a MAGA/GOP crackup:
DOGE is dead, a spectacular failure that leaves behind a post-Musk mess.
Trump’s numbers are godawful. Via Newsweek: 7 polls that show Donald Trump in deep trouble. This one tells the tale:
MTG is out, but apparently, she’s not alone. How pissed are GOP reps? One “particularly exercised senior Republican” told Jake Sherman:
“This entire White House team has treated ALL members like garbage. ALL. And Mike Johnson has let it happen because he wanted it to happen. That is the sentiment of nearly all — appropriators, authorizers, hawks, doves, rank and file. The arrogance of this White House team is off putting to members who are run roughshod and threatened. They don’t even allow little wins like announcing small grants or even responding from agencies. Not even the high profile, the regular rank and file random members are more upset than ever. Members know they are going into the minority after the midterms.
“More explosive early resignations are coming. It’s a tinder box. Morale has never been lower. Mike Johnson will be stripped of his gavel and they will lose the majority before this term is out.”The GOP gerrymandering ploy looks… problematic. Via Puck:
If the new Texas map is ultimately struck down, and Democrats’ own revenge redistricting effort in California stands, Republicans could lose the House before a vote is even cast.
Indeed, immediately after the lower court ruling, I received an expletive-laced call from a Texas G.O.P. consultant. This person’s fury was not unique. Of the dozens of conversations I’ve had since Trump’s initial redistricting blitz this summer, I’ve only heard one Hill Republican praise the idea. G.O.P. distaste for the campaign has only grown since, especially after California passed its redistricting referendum. Now, as the generic ballot shifts further in Dems’ favor, the most likely outcome of new Republican maps would be that Democrats lose some seats in Republican-controlled states, while Republican incumbents lose some in Democratic states—in other words, a nine-figure wash.Congressional Republicans torpedoed Trump’s latest Obamacare scheme, even as Politico reports, “Mike Johnson is losing control of the House.” Quipped Amy Walters:
“I’m reminded of this John Boehner quote he gave in 2017:
“In the 25 years I served in the United States Congress, Republicans never, ever, one time, agreed on what a healthcare proposal should look like. Not once.”It’s starting to dawn on the GOP that tying their fate to an erratic narcissist is a suboptimal choice: “Republican lawmakers grow alarmed over signs of 2026 election wipeout” — The Hill.
Most concerning for GOP lawmakers is Trump’s approval rating, which has sunk to 41.9 percent in the most recent polling average compiled by Decision Desk HQ (DDHQ). The president’s disapproval rating has climbed to 55.7 percent.
Another disquieting sign is that Democrats now have their biggest lead of the election cycle on the generic ballot for Congress. The latest DDHQ average shows Democrats beating Republicans 46.8 percent to 41.4 percent on the generic ballot.
**
Meanwhile: Trump boycotts the G20 summit and nobody seems to care. Actually, everyone seems to have rather enjoyed Trump’s absence. The Empty Chair in Johannesburg: Trump Skips the G20, the World Moves On
Today’s Podcast
Subscribers can listen to an ad-free version right here… or you can watch on YouTube / Listen (and subscribe) on Apple/ Spotify / iHeart / RSS Feed.
Tuesday dogs
Auggie gives me The Look.






The majority of the GOP politicians are still only willing to stick a toe in the water of being anti-Trump and that's only under the cover of darkness and when they think Trump's not looking. He starts winning again...and they'll be by his side in a heartbeat....saying "We were always behind you, sir!"
Those same politicians will also be willing to jump on the side "We really hated Trump the entire time" as soon as they feel zero political risk in doing so.
Is it any wonder that the GOP didn't help our country prevent Trump from acquiring such power since the beginning? A bunch of cowards who cosplay as patriots.
Stand Senator Mark Kelly up alongside Trump or Pete Hegseth. There is NO comparison. One has served his country at the highest levels, and lived through the horror of political violence in his own life, versus two shallow bullies with egos out of control, drunk on power, or worse. Mark Kelly has more integrity in his big toe than Trump does in his whole body.
Mark Kelly spoke the truth, he is being investigated for the ‘crime’ of telling people not to commit crimes. Our service members are sworn to not to follow unlawful orders. No amount of Trump throwing a fit is going to change that. Mark won't stand by and let Trump intimidate our brave soldiers into obeying illegal orders. Mark is standing in the breach against this tyrant and so should we!
This ‘We the People will NOT comply with tyranny‘ shirt is more alive than ever before 👇
https://libtees.dashery.com/products/78688428-we-the-people-will-not-comply-with-tyranny-t-shirt
Attacking an American hero is another reason veterans should reject Trump and everyone/everything associated with him.